Should the media have seen the financial crisis coming? A new book examines the evidence

Should the media have seen the financial crisis coming? A new book examines the evidence

Bassam Sebti, IJNet Arabic Editor | October 15, 2010

Ever since the U.S. banking system triggered a global financial crisis in 2007, journalists have been accused of failing to cover the story early enough. Financial experts and even journalists have asked if better coverage of economic developments early on could have prompted political action to prevent the banking crisis from becoming a global recession that has forced millions of people out of their jobs.

This discussion is the crux of a new book, entitled Covering the Crisis: The Role of Media in the Financial Crisis, published recently by the Netherlands-based European Journalism Center (EJC). The book was published under a Non-Commercial Creative Commons License.

It includes transcripts from a 2009 EJC conference that was held in Brussels under the same title. There, politicians, social scientists, financial regulators, bankers and other experts from Europe and the United States discussed the role of financial reporting and the international monetary system.

"The idea [behind the conference] was to get everybody in one room, close the door and let everybody speak as freely as possible," said EJC Director Wilfried Ruetten. They explored whether journalists could have--and should have--seen the crisis coming.

Journalists covering financial markets were "too close" to the topic, Ruetten said. "They didn’t step back and look at the bigger picture."

Bloomberg News London bureau chief Mark Gilbert disagrees, and in the book, defends the coverage. "I am [going to] argue that we did see the crisis coming. We commented on it. We pointed it out and all of the signs were there that this was [going to] to be big, bad and nasty," he said.

Media critic Danny Schechter, nicknamed "The News Dissector,” thinks the financial crisis should have been covered as a crime story, not a financial one. Schechter is the author of The Crime of Our Time, a book on the theme.

"If [crime reporters] had been actually looking at how these scams and schemes were taking place, they would have brought us to our senses a lot quicker than the financial journalists did," he said in a speech at the conference.

A recent study by Pew Research Center’s Project for Excellence in Journalism sheds light on the question of how aggressive the press was in covering the story in the United States. The study finds that overall, about one-fifth of financial stories were triggered primarily by the initiative of journalists. But the degree of media enterprise varied notably depending on the topic; bigger topics tended to get less enterprise reporting while smaller ones had more.

That, according to Ruetten, is mainly because journalists are deadline-driven. "A lot of the blame falls with assignment editors and senior editors," he said. "They should have seen so many little stories coming and asked 'Is there a bigger picture behind this?' "



Interesting article, Bassam.

Interesting article, Bassam. A hundred years ago, the muckraking journalist Lincoln Steffens said you can beat the people to the news but you can´t beat them to the truth. In other words, they don´t want to hear the truth until they´re ready for it. And they´re not ready for it until it affects them directly.
There were plenty of people warning about the overheated financial markets, but they were ignored. It´s human nature to ignore warnings until something bad happens. As long as everyone was making money and the stock market was going up, it was in everyone´s interest to enjoy the ride. When the roller coaster crashed, then the finger-pointing started.
There´s an analogy with cheap gasoline. We have it in part because of deep-ocean drilling. No one wanted to hear about the risks that such drilling posed. Now they want to blame BP, the regulators, the subcontractors, everyone else.

media methodology in covering issues like the financial crisis

The problem with the coverage that the news media could have given this issue is similar to Jon Stewart's point about the news media seems to be more interested in being entertaining or funny or clever -- more like his show -- than in being the media of Murrow and Cronkite --informative and factual. The media coverage seems to be determined to have an opinion and be a player in the discussions rather than letting us determine our own opinions after we've gotten all the news there is. I know that there's a financial excuse for making the news 'palatable' and more popular, but it's become decidedly not the voice of intelligence or education or enlightenment.

شات مصرية - دردشة مصرية - شات

#22229C" href=""> شات مصرية - دردشة مصرية - شات مصري

#22229C" href=""> شات القاهرة ، دردشة القاهرة ، شات دردشة القاهرة ، شات دردشة جامعة القاهرة

#22229C" href=""> شات الاسكندرية - دردشة الاسكندرية - شات دردشة الاسكندرية - شات دردشة جامعة الاسكندرية

#22229C" href=""> شات المنصورة - دردشة المنصورة

#22229C" href=""> شات البحيرة - دردشة البحيرة

#22229C" href=""> شات الفيوم - دردشة الفيوم

#22229C" href=""> شات الغربية - دردشة الغربية

#22229C" href=""> شات الدقهلية - دردشة الدقهلية

#22229C" href=""> شات الاسماعيلية - دردشة الاسماعيلية

#22229C" href=""> شات الجيزة - دردشة الجيزة

#22229C" href=""> شات المنوفية - دردشة المنوفية

#22229C" href=""> شات المنيا - دردشة المنيا

#22229C" href=""> شات البحر الاحمر - دردشة البحر الاحمر

#22229C" href=""> شات القليوبية - دردشة القليوبية

#22229C" href=""> شات الاقصر - دردشة الاقصر

#22229C" href=""> شات الوادى الجديد - دردشة الوادى الجديد

#22229C" href=""> شات الشرقية - دردشة الشرقية

#22229C" href=""> شات السويس - دردشة السويس

#22229C" href=""> شات اسوان - دردشة اسوان

#22229C" href=""> شات اسيوط - دردشة اسيوط

#22229C" href=""> شات بني سويف - دردشة بني سويف

#22229C" href=""> شات بورسعيد - دردشة بورسعيد

#22229C" href=""> شات دمياط - دردشة دمياط

#22229C" href=""> شات كفر الشيخ - دردشة كفر الشيخ

#22229C" href=""> شات مطروح - دردشة مطروح

#22229C" href=""> شات قنا - دردشة قنا

#22229C" href=""> شات جنوب سيناء - دردشة جنوب سيناء

#22229C" href=""> شات شمال سيناء - دردشة شمال سيناء

#22229C" href=""> شات سوهاج - دردشة سوهاج

#22229C" href=""> شات عسل ـ دردشة عسل

#22229C" href=""> شات الشلة ـ دردشة الشلة

#22229C" href=""> شات فلة ـ دردشة فله

#22229C" href=""> شات دردشة ـ دردشة دردشة

#22229C" href=""> شات شبيك لبيك ـ دردشة شبيك لبيك

#22229C" href=""> شات العنابى ـ دردشة العنابى

شات حب شات الحب دردشة حب حب شات حب شات حبي الحب شات دردشة مصرية شات مصرى شات مصرية دردشة مصراوية شات بنات مصر شات سوريا شات عمان شات لبنان شات بنات شات المنصورة شات القليوبية شات المنوفية دردشة ليبيا شات السودان شات اليمن دردشة بنات السعودية دردشة السعودية شات سعودي دردشة بنات فلسطين دردشة بنات الكويت شات بنات الامارات شات بنات البحرين دردشة قطرية دردشة بنات قطر شات بنات الاردن دردشة عربية شات بنات تونس شات القاهرة دردشة القاهرة دردشة الاسكندرية شات اليكس شات الجيزة دردشة الجيزة راديو اف ام Fm Radio راديو محطة مصر شات الجزائر دردشة الجزائر شات مغربي دردشة بنات المغرب شات الشلة شات دردشة شات دمياط شات بورسعيد اذاعة القران الكريم راديو قران كريم دردشه الغردقة شات شرم الشيخ دردشة الاقصر شات اسوان دردشه المنيا دردشة الحب شات حبنا شات دردشة شات غرام دردشة غرام شات عسل شات عشق شات سعودي كول شات العنابي شات الملك شات برق دردشة برق شات دلع شات لمسة حب شات شوبيك لوبيك شات تعب قلبي شات عسل راديو روتانا